Islamorada Fish Company

Gerald Vargas Edited a month ago

Every time we visit Bass Pro Shops, we make it a point to sit down for a meal at the Islamorada Fish Company—whether it’s for lunch or dinner depending on the time of day. To be honest, one of the main reasons we keep coming back is for the complimentary bread they bring to the table. It is incredibly good and completely addicting! Beyond that, the food overall is always good, and you can't beat the sheer convenience of having a reliable sit-down restaurant right inside the store while you're out shopping. The service is always okay—it gets the job done and keeps the meal moving. It’s just a great, dependable spot to relax, enjoy some amazing bread, and recharge. However, this time in particular our waited TifannyAnne was very attentive and always looking out for our table.

TheCaveBear 3 months ago

Great seafood but a little pricey. Jennifer started with a complementary loaf of what appeared to be fresh baked bread covered with sugar crystals with butter. I don’t know if my bread was intentionally served this way but I was anticipating warm bread and this felt like it had been cooked and sat on the counter about four hours ago. It was a little difficult to cut and the sugar kept flaking off. You need to Cut it, butter it, then pick up some of the sugar crystals and sprinkle it on the butter side. It was OK but I think it would’ve been much better warm. Now, they are New England clam chowder is absolutely fantastic! The potatoes or firm yet cooked in a rich creamy base with plenty of clams. I would’ve been completely satisfied with a full bowl of the clam chowder instead of just a cup and some grilled shrimp on the side. The shrimp were cooked and seasoned beautifully. I did have to do a little extra cleaning on one of the shrimp. I squeezed a couple wine wedges over the shrimp and that really good mark. The green beans were OK, but not very flavorful and a little too far for my personal preference. The rice was seasoned well and had a good flavor. Overall the meal was good

Amelia Ram 4 months ago

Natilie was amazing. She took the time to explain the menu items and had great knowledge of the menu. She was happy and upbeat. Looking forward to dining here again. Krystal came and checked on us too. She was very personable and educated us on different events happening at Bass Pro Shops. The hibiscus Mimosa is fantastic too.

ByHaidee 4 months ago

I had a great experience at Islamorada Fish Company. I ordered the catch of the day along with the key lime pie, and everything was absolutely delicious. The fish was perfectly cooked and full of flavor, and the key lime pie was the perfect sweet ending to the meal. On top of that, our server Natilie provided excellent service—she was attentive, friendly, and made the whole experience even better. Definitely a place I would come back to. Highly recommend!

nick ciranni 7 months ago

An unexpected pleasure in both food quality, service and atmosphere. Very tasty grouper Reuben on crispy Texas toast. Tasty peas. Key lime buttered mahi mahi was very good. Our friend loved the fish tacos. Beautiful fish tank